Robert W. Service

by George J. Dance

Robert W. Service (1874-1958), circa 1905 - Courtesy Wikimedia Commons.

Robert W. Service
Born	Robert William Service January 16, 1874 Preston, Lancashire, England
Died	September 11, 1958 Lancieux, Cotes-d'Armor, France
Occupation	writer
Nationality	Canadian
Ethnicity	Scottish
Citizenship	British subject
Alma mater	Hillhead High School, Glasgow
Notable work(s)	Songs of a Sourdough (1907), Rhymes of a Red Cross Man (1916)
Spouse(s)	Germaine Bourgoin
Children	1 daughter (Iris)

Robert William Service (January 16, 1874 - September 11, 1958) was a British-born Canadian poet and novelist who has often been called "the Bard of the Yukon".

Life

Overview

Service is best known for his poems "The Shooting of Dan McGrew" and "The Cremation of Sam McGee", from his debut collection, Songs of a Sourdough (1907; also published as The Spell of the Yukon, and other verses). "These humorous tales in verse were considered doggerel by the literary set, yet remain extremely popular to this day." Songs of a Sourdough has sold more than 3,000,000 copies, making it the most commercially successful book of poetry of the 20th century.

Commemorative Plaque in Preston, England. Courtesy Wikimedia Commons.

Youth

Service was born in Preston, Lancashire, England, the oldest of 10 children. His father, also Robert Service, was a banker from Kilwinning, Scotland who had been transferred to England.

At 5 years old Robert W. Service went to live in Kilwinning with his 3 maiden aunts and his paternal grandfather, who was the town's postmaster. There he is said to have composed his earliest verse, a grace, on his 6th birthday:

God bless the cakes and bless the jam;

Bless the cheese and the cold boiled ham:

Bless the scones Aunt Jeannie makes,

And save us all from bellyaches. Amen

At 9, Service rejoined his parents who had moved to Glasgow. He attended Glasgow's Hillhead High School.

"Service worked in a bank after he left school" ("he joined the Commercial Bank of Scotland which today is the Royal Bank of Scotland"). He was writing at this time and reportedly already "selling his verses". He was also reading poetry: Browning, Keats, Tennyson, and Thackeray.

In Canada

Service moved to Canada at the age of 21 and travelled to Vancouver Island, British Columbia with his Buffalo Bill outfit and dreams of becoming a cowboy. He drifted around western North America, "wandering from California to British Columbia," taking and quitting a series of jobs: "Starving in Mexico, residing in a California bordello, farming on Vancouver Island, and pursuing unrequited love in Vancouver."

In 1899 Service was a store clerk in Cowichan Bay, British Columbia. He mentioned to a customer (Charles H. Gibbons, editor of the Victoria Daily Colonist) that he wrote verses, with the result that 6 poems by "R.S." on the Boer Wars had appeared in the Colonist by July 1900 – including "The March of the Dead" that would later appear in his first book. (Service's brother Alick was a prisoner of the Boers at the time, having been captured on November 15, 1899, alongside Winston Churchill.)

The Colonist also published Service's "Music in the Bush" on September 18, 1901, and "The Little Old Log Cabin" on March 16, 1902.

In her 2006 biography, Under the Spell of the Yukon, Enid Mallory revealed that Service had fallen in love during this period. He was working as a "farm labourer and store clerk when he first met Constance MacLean at a dance in Duncan B.C, where she was visiting her uncle." MacLean lived in Vancouver, on the mainland, so he courted her by mail. Though he was smitten, "MacLean was looking for a man of education and means to support her" so was not that interested. To please her, he took courses at McGill University's Victoria College, but failed.

Down on his luck in 1903, Service was hired by a Canadian Bank of Commerce branch in Victoria, British Columbia, using his Commercial Bank letter of reference. The bank "watched him, gave him a raise, and sent him to Kamloops in the middle of British Columbia. In Victoria he lived over the bank with a hired piano, and dressed for dinner. In Kamloops, horse country, he played polo. In the fall of 1904 the bank sent him to their Whitehorse branch in the Yukon. With the expense money he bought himself a raccoon coat."

Throughout this period, Service continued writing and saving his verses: "more than a third of the poems in his first volume had been written before he moved north in 1904."

Yukon period

Robert W. Service interview (recalling Yukon) Monaco, 1958

Whitehorse was a frontier town, less than 10 years old. Located on the Yukon River at the Whitehorse Rapids, it had begun in 1897 as a campground for prospectors on their way to Dawson City to join the Klondike Gold Rush. The railroad that Service rode in on had reached Whitehorse only in 1900.

Settling in, "Service dreamed and listened to the stories of the great gold rush." He also "took part in the extremely active Whitehorse social life. As was popular at the time he recited at concerts – things like 'Casey at the Bat' and 'Gunga Din', but they were getting stale."

One day (Service later wrote), while pondering what to recite at an upcoming church concert he met E.J. "Stroller" White, editor of the Whitehorse Star. White suggested: "Why don't you write a poem for it? Give us something about our own bit of earth. We sure would appreciate it. There's a rich paystreak waiting for someone to work. Why don't you go in and stake it?"

Returning from a walk on a Saturday night, Service heard the sounds of revelry from a saloon, and the phrase "A bunch of the boys were whooping it up" popped into his head. Inspired, he ran to the bank to write it down (almost being shot as a burglar), and by the next morning "The Shooting of Dan McGrew" was complete.

"A month or so later he heard a gold rush yarn from a Dawson mining man about a fellow who cremated his pal." He spent the night walking in the woods composing "The Cremation of Sam McGee," and wrote it down from memory the next day.

Other verses quickly followed. "In the early spring he stood above the heights of Miles Canyon ... the line 'I have gazed on naked grandeur where there's nothing else to gaze on' came into his mind and again he hammered out a complete poem, "The Call of the Wild". Conversations with locals led Service to write about things he had not seen (some of which had not actually happened) as well. (He did not set foot in Dawson City until 1908, arriving in the Klondike 10 years after the Gold Rush when his renown as a writer was already established.)

After having collected enough verses for a book, Service "sent the poems to his father, who had emigrated to Toronto, and asked him to find a printing house so they could make it into a booklet. He enclosed a cheque to cover the costs and intended to give these booklets away to his friends in Whitehorse" for Christmas. His father took the manuscript to the Methodist Book Publishing House (MBPH) in Toronto, whose employees loved the book. "The foreman and printers recited the ballads while they worked. A salesman read the proofs out loud as they came off the typesetting machines." An "enterprising salesman sold 1700 copies in advance orders from galley proofs." The publisher "sent Robert's cheque back to him and offered a ten percent royalty contract for the book."

Service's book, Songs of a Sourdough, was "an immediate success." It went through 7 printings even before its official release date. Ultimately, MBPH "sold fifteen impressions in 1907. That same year there was an edition in New York, Philadelphia, and London. The London publisher, T. Fisher Unwin, struck a twenty-third printing in 1910, and thirteen more by 1917." "Service eventually earned in excess of $100,000 for Songs of a Sourdough alone (Mackay 14, 408n19)."

(In the United States, the book was given the more Jack London-ish title, The Spell of the Yukon, and other verses).

"When copies of the book reached Whitehorse, Robert's own minister took him aside to let him know how wicked were his stories. Service hung his head in shame.... But, that summer, tourists from the south arrived in Whitehorse looking for the famous poet; and he autographed many of his books."

"In 1908, after working for the bank for three years in Whitehorse, he was sent outside on mandatory paid leave for three months, a standard practice for bank employees serving in the Yukon." According to Enid Mallory, he went to Vancouver and looked up Constance MacLean. Now that he was a successful author, she agreed to become engaged to him.

Following his leave, in 1908 the bank transferred Service to Dawson, where he met and talked to veterans of the Gold Rush, now 10 years in the past: "they loved to reminisce, and Robert listened carefully and remembered." He used their tales to write a 2nd book of verse, Ballads of a Cheechako, in 1908. "It too was an overwhelming success."

Robert Service at his cabin in Dawson City, Yukon. Courtesy Wikimedia Commons.

In 1909, when the bank wanted Service to return to Whitehorse as manager, he decided to resign. "After quitting his job, he rented a small two-room cabin on Eighth Avenue in Dawson City from Mrs. Edna Clarke and began his career as a full-time author."

He immediately "went to work on his novel.... He went for walks that lasted all night, slept till mid-afternoon, and sometimes didn't come out of the cabin for days. In five months the novel, called The Trail of '98, was complete and he took it to a publisher in New York." Service's debut novel also "immediately became a best-seller."

Newly wealthy, Service was able to travel to Paris, the French Riviera, Hollywood, and beyond. He returned to Dawson City in 1912 to write his 3rd book of poetry, Rhymes of a Rolling Stone (1912). During that time he became a freemason, being initiated into Yukon Lodge No. 45 in Dawson.

It is not known what happened between Service and Constance MacLean. There are no known letters between then from after the time Service went to Dawson City. In 1912 she "married Leroy Grant, a surveyor and railroad engineer based in Prince Rupert."

Later life

Robert Service Memorial, Kilwinning, Ayrshire. Photo by Roger Griffith. Courtesy Wikimedia Commons.

Service left Dawson City for good in 1912. From 1912 to 1913 he was a correspondent for the Toronto Star during the Balkan Wars.

In 1913 Service arrived in Paris, where he would live for the next 15 years. He settled in the Latin Quarter, posing as a painter. In June 1913 he married Parisienne Germaine Bougeoin, daughter of a distillery owner, and they purchased a summer home at Lancieux, Cotes-d'Armor, in the Brittany region of France. 13 years younger than her husband, Germaine Service lived 31 years following his death, dying at age 102 in 1989.

Service was 41 when World War I broke out; he enlisted, but was turned down "due to varicose veins." He briefly covered the war for the Toronto Star (from December 11, 1915 through January 29, 1916), but "was arrested and nearly executed in an outbreak of spy hysteria in Dunkirk." – then "worked as a stretcher bearer and ambulance driver with the Ambulance Corps of the American Red Cross, until his health broke." Convalescing in Paris, he wrote a new book of mainly war poetry, Rhymes of a Red Cross Man, in 1916. The book was dedicated to the memory of Service's "brother, Lieutenant Albert Service, Canadian Infantry, Killed in Action, France, August 1916."

With the end of the war, Service "settled down to being a rich man in Paris.... During the day he would promenade in the best suits, with a monocle. At night he went out in old clothes with the company of his doorman, a retired policeman, to visit the lowest dives of the city.". During his time in Paris he was reputedly the wealthiest author living in the city, yet was known to dress as a working man and walk the streets, blending in and observing everything around him. Those experiences would be used in his next book of poetry, Ballads of a Bohemian (1921), "The poems are given in the persona of an American poet in Paris who serves as an ambulance driver and an infantryman in the war. The verses are separated by diary entries over a period of four years."

In the 1920s Service began writing thriller novels. The Poisoned Paradise, A Romance of Monte Carlo (New York, 1922) and The Roughneck. A Tale of Tahiti (New York, 1923) would both be made into silent movies.

In 1930 Service returned to Kilwinning, to erect a memorial to his family in the town cemetery. He also visited the USSR in the 1930s, and later wrote a satirical "Ballad of Lenin's Tomb". For this reason his poetry has never been translated into Russian in the USSR and he was never mentioned in Soviet encyclopedias.

Service's 2nd trip to the Soviet Union "was interrupted by news of the Hitler-Stalin pact. Service fled across Poland, Latvia, Estonia and the Baltic to Stockholm. He wintered in Nice with his family, then fled France for Canada." Not long after, the Germans invaded France, and "arrived at his home in Lancieux ... looking specifically for the poet who had mocked Hitler in newspaper verse."

During World War II Service lived in California, "and Hollywood had him join with other celebrities to help the morale of troops, visiting US Army camps to recite his poems. He was also asked to play himself in the movie The Spoilers, working alongside Marlene Dietrich and John Wayne." "He was thrilled to play a scene with Marlene Dietrich."

After the war Service and his wife returned to his home in Brittany, to find it destroyed. They rebuilt, and he lived there until his death in 1958, though he wintered in Monte Carlo on the French Riviera.

Service's wife and daughter, Iris, travelled to the Yukon in 1946 "and visited Whitehorse and Dawson City, which by then was becoming a ghost town. Service could not bring himself to go back. He preferred to remember the town as it had been."

Service wrote prolifically during his last years, publishing six books of verse from 1949 to 1955 (with one more appearing posthumously the following year).

It was at Service's flat in Monte Carlo that Canadian broadcaster Pierre Berton recorded, over a period of 3 days, many hours of autobiographical television interview, for the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, in the spring of 1958, not long before Service died.

Service wrote 2 volumes of autobiography - Ploughman of the Moon and Harper of Heaven. He died in Lancieux and is buried in the village cemetery.

Writing

Robert Service wrote the most commercially successful poetry of the century. Yet his most popular works "were considered doggerel by the literary set." During his lifetime, he was nicknamed "the Canadian Kipling." – yet that may have been a double-edged compliment. As T.S. Eliot has said, "we have to defend Kipling against the charge of excessive lucidity," against "the charge of being a 'journalist' appealing only to the commonest collective emotion," and against "the charge of writing jingles." All those charges, and more, could be levelled against Service's best known and best loved works.

Certainly Service's verse was derivative of Kipling's: "The Cremation of Sam McGee," for instance, uses the form of Kipling's "Ballad of East and West."

In his E.J. Pratt lecture "Silence In the Sea," critic Northrop Frye argued that Service's verse was not "serious poetry," but something else he called "popular poetry": "the idioms of popular and serious poetry remain inexorably distinct." Popular poems, he thought, "preserve a surface of explicit statement" – either being "proverbial, like Kipling's 'If' or Longfellow's 'Song of Life' or Burns's 'For A' That'," or dealing in "conventionally poetic themes, like the pastoral themes of James Whitcomb Riley, or the adventurous themes of Robert Service."

Service himself did not call his work poetry. "Verse, not poetry, is what I was after ... something the man in the street would take notice of and the sweet old lady would paste in her album; something the schoolboy would spout and the fellow in the pub would quote. Yet I never wrote to please anyone but myself; it just happened. I belonged to the simple folks whom I liked to please.'

In his autobiography, Service described his method of writing at his Dawson City cabin. "I used to write on the coarse rolls of paper used by paper-hangers, pinning them on the wall and printing my verses in big charcoal letters. Then I would pace back and forth before them, repeating them, trying to make them perfect. I wanted to make them appeal to the eye as well as to the ear. I tried to avoid any literal quality."

One remarkable thing about both of Service's best-known ballads is how easily he wrote them. When writing about composing "The Shooting of Dan McGrew," 'easy' was exactly the word he used: "For it came so easy to me in my excited state that I was amazed at my facility. It was as if someone was whispering in my ear." (And this was just after someone had tried to shoot him!) He continued: "As I wrote stanza after stanza, the story seemed to evolve itself. It was a marvelous experience. Before I crawled into my bed at five in the morning, my ballad was in the bag."

Similarly, when he wrote "The Cremation of Sam McGee,", the verses just flowed: "I took the woodland trail, my mind seething with excitement and a strange ecstasy.... As I started in: There are strange things done in the midnight sun, verse after verse developed with scarce a check ... and when I rolled happily into bed, my ballad was cinched. Next day, with scarcely any effort of memory I put it on paper."

In 1926, Archibald MacMechan, Professor of English at Canada's Dalhousie University, pronounced on Service's Yukon books in his Headwaters of Canadian Literature:

The sordid, the gross, the bestial, may sometimes be redeemed by the touch of genius; but that Promethean touch is not in Mr. Service. In manner he is frankly imitative of Kipling's barrack-room balladry; and imitation is an admission of inferiority. 'Sourdough' is Yukon slang for the provident old-timer ... It is a convenient term for this wilfully violent kind of verse without the power to redeem the squalid themes it treats. The Ballads of a Cheechako is a second installment of sourdoughs, while his novel The Trail of '98 is simply sourdough prose.

MacMechan did give grudging respect to Service's war poetry, conceding that his style went well with that subject, and that "his Rhymes of a Red Cross Man are an advance on his previous volumes. He has come into touch with the grimmest of realities; and while his radical faults have not been cured, his rude lines drive home the truth that he has seen."

Reviewing Service's Rhymes of a Rebel in 1952, Frye remarked that the book "interests me chiefly because ... I have noticed so much verse in exactly the same idiom, and I wonder how far Mr. Service's books may have influenced it. There was a time, fifty years ago," he added," when Robert W.Service represented, with some accuracy, the general level of poetic experience in Canada, as far as the popular reader was concerned.... there has been a prodigious, and, I should think, a permanent, change in public taste."

Service has also been noted for his use of ethnonyms, group names that in a 21st-century context would be considered offensive "slurs," but with no insult apparently intended. Words used in Service's poetry include jerries (Germans), dago (Italian), pickaninny (in reference to a Mozambican infant), cheechako (newcomer to the Yukon and Alaska gold fields, usually from the U.S.), n*gger (black person), squaw (Aboriginal woman), and Jap (Japanese).

Recognition

Bust of Service in Whitehorse. Photo by Gareth Sloan. Licensed under Creative Commons, courtesy Wikimedia Commons.

Service has been honored with schools named for him, including Robert Service High School in Anchorage, Alaska; Robert Service Senior Public School (Middle / Jr. High) in Toronto, Ontario; and Robert Service School in Dawson City, Yukon.

He was honored on a Canadian postage stamp in 1976.

Robert Service Way, a main road in Whitehorse, is named after him.

The Bard & Banker public house in Victoria, British Columbia is dedicated to Service, the building having been the Canadian Bank of Commerce branch where he was employed while residing in the city. In 2010 Phillips Brewery in Victoria released the Service 1904 Scottish Stone Fired Ale, available only on tap in 3 Victoria locations: The Bard & Banker, Irish Times, and Penny Farthing public houses.

In popular culture

Service's debut novel, The Trail of '98, was made into a movie by Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, directed by Clarence Brown. "Trail of '98 ... starring Dolores Del Rio, Ralph Forbes and Karl Dante in 1929 ... was the first talking picture dealing with the Klondike gold rush and was acclaimed at the time by critics for depicting the Klondike as it really was."

Folksinger Country Joe McDonald set some of Service's World War I poetry (plus "The March of the Dead" from Songs of a Sourdough), to music for his 1971 studio album, War War War.

Folksinger and poet Donovan Leitch names Service as an early influence:

Donovan in his autobiography names Buddy Holly as being important to him when he was a teenager, and his reading of (and his father's chanting of) Robert W. Service, who he calls "...the Scottish Woody Guthrie, who told of the 'Men who don't fit in...' and who '...break the hearts of kith and kin/ And they roam the world at will.' Yes, I had the 'Curse of Gypsy blood'.

Dawson City cabin

Robert Service lived from 1909 to 1912 in a small two-room cabin on 8th Avenue which he rented from Edna Clarke in Dawson City, Yukon. His prosperity allowed him the luxury of a telephone.

Service eventually decided he could not return to Dawson, as it would not be as he remembered it. He wrote in his autobiography:

"Only yesterday an air-line offered to fly me up there in two days, and I refused. It would have saddened me to see dust and rust where once hummed a rousing town; hundreds where were thousands; tumbledown cabins, mouldering warehouses."

Cabin of Robert Service in Dawson City, Yukon. Photo by Hans-Jürgen Hübner. Courtesy Wikimedia Commons.

After Service left for Europe, the Imperial Order of the Daughters of the Empire (I.O.D.E.) took care of the cabin until 1971, preserving it. In 1971 it was taken over by Parks Canada, which maintains it, including its sod roof, as a tourist attraction.

Irish-born actor Tom Byrne created The Robert Service Show which was presented in the front yard of the cabin, starting in 1976. This was very popular for summer visitors and set the standard for Robert Service recitations. A resurgence in sales of Service's works followed the institution of these performances.

Byrne discontinued the show at the cabin in 1995, moving it to a Front Street storefront. Since 2004 the show has been held at the Westmark Hotel in Dawson City at 3:00 p.m. every day during the summer months. Byrne collects Robert Service 1st editions, and corresponded with Mr. Service's widow for years.

At the Service Cabin, local Dawson entertainers dressed in period costumes and employed by Parks Canada offer biographical information and recite Service's poetry for visitors sitting on benches on the front lawn. Johnny Nunan performed this role through 2006. The present performer shares his first name (Fred). Following the presentation, visitors can view Service's home through the windows and front door. The fragility of the house, and the rarity of the artifacts, precludes any possibility of allowing visitors to enter the house itself.

Publications

Poetry

• Songs of a Sourdough. Toronto: William Briggs, 1907.
  • published in U.S. as The Spell of the Yukon, and other verses. New York: Barse & Hopkins, 1907..
• Ballads of a Cheechako. Toronto: William Briggs, 1909.
• Rhymes of a Rolling Stone. Toronto: William Briggs, 1912.
• Rhymes of a Red Cross Man. Toronto: William Briggs, 1916.
• Ballads of a Bohemian. Toronto: G.J. McLeod, 1921.
• Twenty Bath-Tub Ballads. London: Francis, Day and Hunter, 1939.
• Bar-Room Ballads. New York: Dodd, Mead, 1940.
• Songs of a Sun-Lover. A book of light verse. New York: Dodd, Mead, 1949.
• Rhymes of a Roughneck. A book of verse. New York: Dodd, Mead, 1950.
• Lyrics of a Lowbrow. A book of verse. New York: Dodd, Mead, 1951.
• Rhymes of a Rebel. A book of verse. New York: Dodd, Mead, 1952.
• Songs for my Supper. New York: Dodd, Mead, 1953.
• Carols of an Old Codger. New York: Dodd, Mead, 1955.
• Rhymes for My Rags. New York: Dodd, Mead, 1956.

Novels

• The Trail of '98: A northland romance. Toronto: William Briggs, 1909.
• The Pretender. A story of the Latin quarter. New York: Dodd, Mead, 1914.
• The Poisoned Paradise: A Romance of Monte Carlo. New York: Dodd, Mead, 1922.
• The Roughneck, A Tale of Tahiti. New York: Barse and Hopkins, 1923.
• The Master of the Microbe: A Fantastic Romance. London: T. Fisher Unwin, 1926.
• The House of Fear, A Novel. London: T. Fisher Unwin, 1927.

Non-fiction

• Why Not Grow Young? or Living for Longevity. London: Ernest Benn, 1928.
• Ploughman of the Moon, An Adventure Into Memory (autobiography). New York: Dodd, Mead, 1945.
• Harper of Heaven. A Record of Radiant Living (autobiography). New York: Dodd, Mead, 1948.

Collected editions

• Robert W. Service: Selected poetry and prose (edited by Michael Gnarowski). Toronto: Dundurn Press, 2011.

Robert W. Service The Spell of the Yukon

Except where noted, bibliographical information courtesy RobertService.com.

Poems by Robert W. Service

The Passing of the Year - Robert Service - Read by Jean Shepherd

1. The Call of the Wild
2. The Cremation of Sam McGee
3. The Little Old Log Cabin
4. The March of the Dead
5. Music in the Bush
6. The Shooting of Dan McGrew

See also

• World War I poets
• Scottish-Canadian poets
• List of British poets
• List of Canadian poets
• Timeline of Canadian poetry

External links

Poems

• Robert W. Service profile & 2 poems at the Academy of American Poets
• "The Last Verses of Robert W. Service" (2 poems), Maclean's
• Service, Robert W. (1874-1958) - 4 poems (The Cremation of Sam McGee, The Shooting of Dan McGrew, The Song of the Wage-Slave, The Telegraph Operator) at Representative Poetry Online
• 5 poems by Service: "Just Think!," "The Passing of the Year," "The March of the Dead," "The Pines," "The Stretcher Bearer"
• Robert W. Service 1874-1958 at the Poetry Foundation
• Robert Service's war poetry
• Robert William Service at PoemHunter (832 poems)

Audio / video

• Ballads of a Bohemian by Robert Service at LibriVox
• Robert Service at YouTube

Books

• Works by Robert W. Service at Project Gutenberg
• Robert W. Service at Internet Archive
• Robert W. Service at Amazon.com
• Robert William Service at Amazon.com

About

• Robert William Service in the Canadian Encyclopedia
• Robert W. Service at NNDB
• Robert Service at Electric Scotland
• Robert W. Service at the Ryerson Archive
• RobertWService.com Official website
• Robert W. Service at Find a Grave
• Mossback Minstrelsy: The British Columbia verse of Robert W. Service at Canadian Poetry
• Robert Service's War Correspondence and Poetry at Canadian Poetry
• Interview from 1922

This is a signed article by User:George Dance. It may be edited for spelling errors or typos, but not for substantive content except by its author. If you have created a user name and verified your identity, provided you have set forth your credentials on your user page, you can add comments to the bottom of this article as peer review.